Replay Toys

Write a Review920-659-0869

CLOSED NOW - Opens at 12:00pm

The owner is very nice. The prices are good. He has a very good selection of older toys. He has a lot of 80s action figures and hot wheels. I hope to be back soon!

This is a wonderful store. It is like a walk down memory lane. The owner is very friendly and helpful. I found the prices to be very reasonable! I will be a repeat customer and look forward to letting others know there is a place to find some wonderful unique gifts that will actually mean something to people. I can't wait to find shop here for my parents, sister, and friends. What better gift that to allow them to recapture some great moments with something they loved as a child!

Recently purchased a train set from Replay Toys, originally advertised on Craigslist. The owners were very flexible on picking up the toy on a day the shop was closed and I also bartered with them on the price. Lots of selection and fair prices. Would recommend this store to anyone in the Fox Valley area.

the store is a little unorginized but far from over priced garage sale items.the owners are very friendly and work with you on prices if you are interested on it. like every business that just opens it takes a little time to get it just right but i for one think its a great place and hope its here for along time

This store is more like an overpriced thrift store. 90% of the toys sold here you can buy at a garage sale for less than a dollar. The store is disorganized and it is hard to look through the piles of used board games. The nice toys they do have are grossly overpriced. If you like thrift shop toys at ridiculous prices replay toys is your place.

It was great! If you are looking for a toy that cannot be purched in the stores...they just might have it!