The Eccentric Bagel

Write a Review631-749-5363

CLOSED NOW - Opens at 7:00am

Eccentric Bagel, the ultimate destination for authentic New York bagels and retro pop decor. From Shelter Island locals to tourists to the Hamptons, everyone has been bitten by the Eccentric Bagel shop, and we're not surprised - who wouldn't love a bite of their delicious bagels while watching original MTV and commercials from the 80s playing on their vintage TV. From the classic flavors like plain, sesame, and everything to specialty bagels like garlic parmesan, smoked bacon, and honey and heat. Eccentric Bagel offers a wide variety of bagels that will satisfy your taste buds. But wait, there's more! They also serve a selection of house-made spreads & salads as well as unique sandwiches, and gourmet coffee.Eccentric Bagel, the ultimate destination for authentic New York bagels and retro pop decor. From Shelter Island locals to tourists to the Hamptons, everyone has been bitten by the Eccentric Bagel shop, and we're not surprised - who wouldn't love a bite of their delicious bagels while watching original MTV and commercials from the 80s playing on their vintage TV. From the classic flavors like plain, sesame, and everything to specialty bagels like garlic parmesan, smoked bacon, and honey and heat. Eccentric Bagel offers a wide variety of bagels that will satisfy your taste buds. But wait, there's more! They also serve a selection of house-made spreads & salads as well as unique sandwiches, and gourmet coffee.