Giuseppe's Island Pizzeria

Write a Review973-351-5103

OPEN NOW - Closes at 11:00pm

The worst!!! While staying at a local hotel, I called to place an order. When the person taking my order hung up before I had even finished ordering or payed over the phone, I should have known to just cancel my order then, but instead made the mistake of calling back and giving my credit card info. After waiting 45 minutes, my order was delivered and multiple things were completely incorrect. When I called the place back, I was put on hold multiple times, spoke to 3 different people, and was told that I must have ordered incorrectly. I was then told that if I didn't want the order, I could give it back to the driver. When I asked if the correct order would be sent out I was told I would have to pay for it. When I asked if the food could just be picked up and a refund processed, I was put on hold while they checked. They begrudgingly consented, but I'm not holding my breath. I wouldn't be surprised if the majority of their profit comes from overcharging out-of-towners who won't be around long enough to argue.

I ordered off of grubhub and they got my order completely wrong and the sandwiches they sent barely had any meat on them also when I called they had poor customer service and I had to speak to three different people don't order from here all they want is your money!!!!!! They need to be shut down!!!!!! If I could give this place negative stars I would

I love this place... their food is great and the slice of pizza is as big as 2. The workers are the nicest, they kept a smile on my face the whole time i was there. Every time i'm in hillside i stop by

The pizza was tasteless, all bread no sauce hardly any cheese. Also had clam pasta which wasn't cooked enough. Their food sucks!