Nicky's Pizza

Write a Review845-357-7767

OPEN NOW - Closes at 10:00pm

I ordered Nicky's once a week every week for years and the food has consistently gotten worse. My 5 year old niece wouldn't even eat a slice from there, and I don't know any kid that'll refuse pizza. They are also seriously overpriced! Let's just say my family will choose digiorno over this "pizza" any day!

Worst Pizza in Suffern! Do NOT waste your time. In a town that has 1-2 pizza places per mile it's amazing how this poop-hole stays afloat. I'm not sure I've ever seen an employee wear gloves EVER when handling food. Countless people, myself included have gotten severely sick from eating their food. You feel sticky instantly from just walking through the door. The pizza is absolutely horrid. The owner seems very deep in thought upon first glance, but when attempting to speak to him his attitude matches the restaurant.... NASTY. This place doesn't deserve the one star rating it received from me, but its the lowest rating yellow pages allows. EAT AT YOUR OWN RISK!